How the family ranking works
The ranking is the average of four Locustep scores: schools, healthcare, safety and housing. Safety comes from the FBI's violent crime rate and housing from HUD's Fair Market Rents, both measured. Schools and healthcare are Locustep's directional scores, a broad read on school quality and on access to care, not a test-score league table. The best states for families ranking lists all fifty.
The eight states at the top
| State | Family ranking | Schools score | Violent crime | Two-bedroom rent, per month | Rent as a share of income |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | highest | 3rd highest | 19th lowest | $1,507 | 14th lowest |
| Connecticut | 2nd highest | 2nd highest | 3rd lowest | $2,033 | 10th highest |
| Maine | 3rd highest | 7th highest | lowest | $1,714 | 7th highest |
| Wisconsin | 3rd highest | 7th highest | 21st lowest | $1,251 | 8th lowest |
| Iowa | 5th highest | 14th highest | 15th lowest | $1,113 | 3rd lowest |
| Rhode Island | 6th highest | 7th highest | 4th lowest | $1,911 | 6th highest |
| Vermont | 7th highest | 7th highest | 11th lowest | $1,773 | 9th highest |
| Nebraska | 8th highest | 14th highest | 12th lowest | $1,260 | 9th lowest |
Minnesota comes first, with the 3rd highest schools score and the 2nd highest healthcare score, at rent near the middle of the country. Its winter afternoon highs are the 3rd lowest of any state's reference city, which is the price of admission. Connecticut is second overall, with the 2nd highest schools score, ahead of Minnesota, and the 3rd lowest violent crime rate, but its rent is the 8th highest. Maine has the lowest violent crime rate in the country.
Strong for families and easier on the budget
Three states in the top eight are also easy on the budget. Iowa has the 3rd lowest rent as a share of income and the 2nd lowest everyday costs. Wisconsin ties for third on the family ranking with rent that takes the 8th lowest share of income. Nebraska has the 4th lowest everyday costs. Just outside the eight, North Dakota is 10th highest on the family ranking and has the lowest everyday costs and the lowest rent share of income in the country.
For a family on one local income, those are the states where a good score does not come with a stretched budget. The cheapest states guide has more on how rent and everyday costs differ.
The tradeoff with low taxes
None of the eight states at the top has one of the ten lowest household tax bills. Connecticut has the 3rd highest bill in the country and Minnesota the 13th highest. The reverse also holds: Tennessee and Nevada have the 2nd lowest and 3rd lowest tax bills, and both sit 6th lowest on the family ranking. North Dakota is the rare state that does well on both, with the 4th lowest bill.
The data shows the pattern but not the reason, and there are exceptions. Still, if a low tax bill is your main reason to move, check the schools score of the state you have in mind before you count the saving.
The bottom of the list
Alaska ranks last for families and has the highest violent crime rate in the country. New Mexico is 2nd lowest and has the 2nd highest violent crime rate. Louisiana is 3rd lowest, with the 3rd lowest schools score. California is 4th lowest despite the 4th highest healthcare score; it has the highest rent in the country and the 6th highest violent crime rate.
What the ranking cannot tell you
- Childcare costs are not in the data, and for young children they can outweigh rent.
- School quality varies by district far more than by state. Look up the district for any address you consider.
- Crime rates are state averages; neighborhoods within one city can differ widely.
- Being near family can matter more than any score. The couples guide helps weigh that together.
The free quiz lets you set how much each factor matters to your family and ranks all fifty states on that, instead of on an average. The Move Decision Kit, $39 once, then runs your own household through a chosen state: take-home pay, housing, moving costs and the month the move pays for itself.
Safety is the FBI violent crime rate and housing is HUD Fair Market Rents. Schools and healthcare are Locustep's directional scores. Rent share uses Census median household income; everyday costs are BEA Regional Price Parities without housing; tax bills are Locustep's household estimate.